EU bishops urge court to shield baptism records from erasure
The EU bishops' commission COMECE says baptismal registers record a past sacrament, not church membership, as the EU's top court weighs a Belgian data case
Christian World | The EU bishops' commission COMECE says baptismal registers record a past sacrament, not church membership, as the EU's top court weighs a Belgian data case
ACW | November 21, 2026 — The Commission of the Bishops' Conferences of the European Union (COMECE) on Friday urged the EU's top court not to let people who leave the Church erase their names from baptismal registers.
The case began when a Belgian man, baptised Catholic as a child, asked the Diocese of Ghent to remove every reference to him from its records under the EU's data protection law, the GDPR. The diocese noted that he had left the Church and struck through his entry, but the name stayed legible.
Belgium's data protection authority sided with him and ordered the diocese to erase the data. The diocese challenged the order, and a Belgian court asked the Court of Justice of the European Union how the law should be read.
In an opinion on Oct. 1, Advocate General Laila Medina said the right to erasure "may, in principle, apply" to baptismal registers. The Church could keep the data only if it showed "compelling legitimate grounds," she said, leaving national courts to weigh each case.
COMECE rejected that reading in a position paper published Nov. 20. "Baptismal registers do not record present membership, but rather document a historical and sacramental fact," it said. In the Catholic Church, it added, baptism is the "gateway" to the other sacraments. The bishops also dismissed fixes such as covering names with "opaque stickers."
COMECE first set out its view on the case in September. It said it hopes the final ruling ensures "full protection of baptismal registers from erasure."
Photo: FrDr / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)